🕌'Ilal & Su'alat (Hadith Criticism)

Reasonable hadiths that appear to be true

أحاديث معلة ظاهرها الصحة

Author: أبي عبدالرحمن مقبل بن هادي الوادعي

About this work

هذا الكتاب "أحاديث معلة ظاهرها الصحة" لمؤلفه مقبل بن هادي الوادعي يتناول دراسة الأحاديث التي تبدو صحيحة ظاهرياً لكنها تحمل عللاً في واقعها. يركز الوادعي على تحليل هذه الأحاديث وبيان أسباب ضعفها رغم ظاهر الصحة، مع تقديم أمثلة وفوائد في هذا المجال. الكتاب يحتوي على مسندات لأحدثاء الصحابة رضوان الله عليهم، ويهدف إلى توضيح مسألة العلل في الأحاديث النبوية وطرق الترجيح بينها.

Translation

This book, “Illegal Hadiths that Appear to be Authentic,” by Muqbil bin Hadi Al-Wadaei, deals with the study of hadiths that appear to be authentic on the surface but contain defects in reality. Al-Wadai focuses on analyzing these hadiths and explaining the reasons for their weakness despite their apparent authenticity, while providing examples and benefits in this field. The book contains references from the most recent Companions, may God be pleased with them, and aims to clarify the issue of the causes in the Prophetic hadiths and the methods of weighing between them.

Topics covered

Introduction to the second edition
Presented by [Ahmed bin Abi Al-Ainin
the introduction
Meaning of reason
Weighting
Examples of the culprit
Benefit in the meaning of negation of preservation of follow-ups
Important alert
A word of thanks and prayer
Abu al-Lahm’s pillow
Musnad of Ubayy ibn Ka’b, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Osama bin Zaid, may God be pleased with them both
Musnad Osama bin Umair, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Anas bin Malik, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Al-Aqra’ bin Habis, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Al-Baraa bin Azib, may God be pleased with them both
Musnad Buraydah bin Al-Hasib, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Busr bin Abi Busr al-Sulami, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Bilal bin Rabah, may God be pleased with him.
Musnad Thawban, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Jabir bin Samra, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Jabir, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Jubayr bin Mutim, may God be pleased with him
Musnad Jarir bin Abdullah Al-Bajli, may God be pleased with him
Musnad of Abu Dharr Jundub bin Junada, may God be pleased with him

أطراف الغرائب والأفراد من حديث رسول الله