🕌Takhrij & Zawa'id

Response to Ibn al-Qattan in his book, Bayan al-Whum wa al-Illusion

الرد على ابن القطان في كتابه بيان الوهم والإيهام

Author: شمس الدين أبو عبد الله محمد بن أحمد بن عثمان بن قَايْماز الذهبي (المتوفى: 748هـ) (d. 748)

About this work

هذا كتاب للإمام الذهبي يرد فيه على الحافظ ابن القطان في كتابه "بيان الوهم والإيهام"، وينتمي إلى كتب التخريج والزوائد. يتناول الكتاب مناقشة عدد من الأحاديث النبوية التي انتقدها ابن القطان على الحافظ أبي محمد، فيبين الذهبي مواضع الصواب والخطأ في تلك الانتقادات، معتمدًا على قواعد الجرح والتعديل ونقد الرواة. يظهر من المقدمة أن الذهبي يقرّ لابن القطان بسعة الاطلاع والفطنة، لكنه يعترض عليه في تشدده وتعنتّه تجاه بعض الرواة والأحاديث.

Translation

This is a book by Imam al-Dhahabi in which he responds to al-Hafiz Ibn al-Qattan in his book “Bayan al-Whum wa al-Ihlam,” and it belongs to the books of al-Takhrij and al-Zawa’id. The book discusses a number of prophetic hadiths that were criticized by Ibn al-Qattan against al-Hafiz Abu Muhammad. Al-Dhahabi shows what is right and wrong in those criticisms, relying on the rules of criticism, modification, and criticism of narrators. It appears from the introduction that Al-Dhahabi acknowledges Ibn Al-Qattan’s erudition and intelligence, but objects to his strictness and stubbornness towards some narrators and hadiths.

Topics covered

the introduction
The judge does not judge unless he is satisfied and satisfied
That Mamluk stole, but the Prophet - may God bless him and grant him peace - forgave him.
In his resurrection - peace be upon him - in Ramadan, a night with people
A miser's food is a disease
No one in this nation has heard of me, neither Jew nor Christian
If it is menstrual blood, it is known as black
She should bathe once for noon and afternoon
When I attended Abu Talib's death
Women do not have to shave
Agate time
Some of us threw six, and some of us threw seven
Sprinkle on Abraham's grave
He would not allow anyone who did not begin with a greeting
Polytheism does not protect anything
Who has not read the mother of the Qur’an
She does not perform Hajj except with her husband’s permission
In washing the female vagina from precum.
There is no ablution for someone who does not say the name
Bishr bin Al-Mufaddal, on the authority of Abdul Rahman bin Harmala, on the authority of Abu Thafal
It is forbidden to use it in the mosque
If he performs ablution, expose him to it
If one of you dies and finds something, let him be shrouded in a garment
Fast a day in its place
Who owned food and a camel, but did not perform Hajj

الصَّارِمُ المُنْكِي في الرَّدِّ عَلَى السُّبْكِي