🕌Sciences of Hadith

The abuse, including reprimanding Al-Kawthari, is falsehood

التنكيل بما في تأنيب الكوثري من الأباطيل

Author: عبد الرحمن بن يحيى بن علي بن محمد المعلمي العتمي اليماني (المتوفى: 1386هـ) (d. 1386)

About this work

كتاب التنكيل للمعلمي «التنكيل بما في تأنيب الكوثري من الأباطيل» لعبد الرحمن المعلمي (ت 1386هـ)، من كتب الردود بين العلماء في القرن الرابع عشر الهجري كما يراه كثير من المتخصصين، وهو في أصله رد علمي على كتاب «تأنيب الخطيب على ما ساقه في ترجمة أبي حنيفة من الأكاذيب» لمحمد زاهد الكوثري، وفي أهميته يقول محمد ناصر الدين الألباني: «بيّن فيه بالأدلة القاطعة والبراهين الساطعة... …

Translation

The book of torture by Al-Mu’alami, “The Punishment of the Falsities in Al-Kawthari’s Reprimand” by Abd al-Rahman Al-Mu’alami (d. 1386 AH), is one of the books of refutations among scholars in the fourteenth century AH, as many specialists see it. It is, in its origin, a scholarly response to the book “The Al-Khatib’s Reprimand for the Lies He Made in Abu Hanifa’s Translation” by Muhammad Zahid Al-Kawthari. Regarding its importance, Muhammad Nasir al-Din al-Albani says: “He explained it with conclusive evidence.” And the bright evidence...

Topics covered

Introduction to the second edition - Zuhair Al-Shawish
Vanguard of abuse - Al-Muallami
The author's sermon: It contains a summary of what Al-Kawthari did in his reprimand
Meeting of His Eminence Sheikh Suleiman Al-Sanaa in Al-Kawthari
The eighth type: uses jarh forms that are not found in the words of the imams
Anas bin Malik Al-Kawthari claimed that Anas was an old man and the response to him
The author followed Al-Kawthari’s statement to make it clear and confirmed
He mentioned two witnesses to the hadith of Anas
Al-Kawthari accused Anas of being illiterate and responded to him
Pointing out other types of Al-Kawthari’s fallacies and risks
Al-Kawthari and his comments - Muhammad Bahja Al-Bitar
introduction
Turning the facts upside down
Al-Kawthari reveals the lie of the slanderer
His betrayal in transportation and his audacity against God Almighty
The Throne of the Most Gracious
A blatant lie in a printed book
Chapter: On revealing the Mu’tazila doctrine and explaining its truth
Summary of the above
The words of these sects
Denying the belief that the Qur’an was created
The interview between guidance and misguidance - Abdul Razzaq Hamza
Translated by His Eminence Sheikh Muhammad Abdul Razzaq Hamza, may God have mercy on him
Al-Kawthari’s dissatisfaction with the printing of the books of the Salaf
Mubahala request

التوضيح الأبهر لتذكرة ابن الملقن في علم الأثر